Beauty

9 Best Gel Eyeliners That Are Smudge-Free and Tug-Free

If pencils and liquids aren't working, try a gel eyeliner! They go on your waterline and oily lids just as well. Get the best one from our list here.


Editor · 24 Jan 2019, 7:21pm

Some links in this guide are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we pick or how we rank them.

9 Best Gel Eyeliners That Are Smudge-Free and Tug-Free

Bring more attention to your eyes by simply using an eyeliner to further define it. From liquid eyeliner to gel eyeliner, there are many brands to choose from that offers different colours and formulas. Listed below are some of the best gel eyeliners to up your eye makeup game.

Contents
Best for mature eyes 1 of 9
Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Matte Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner
Partnership with Marc Jacobs Beauty
From RM103
See price at Sephora Malaysia

Formulated to give you a smooth glide, this gel eyeliner by Marc Jacobs applies smoothly for mature eyes and does not tug on your lids. With strong staying power, you don’t have to worry about it flaking or budging. It is also waterproof. 

Best waterproof eyeliner for waterline
Best for waterline 2 of 9
Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner
Partnership with Marc Jacobs Beauty
From RM113
See price at Sephora Malaysia

This award winning gel eyeliner doubles as an eyeshadow that applies smoothly on your waterline. Its gentle formula is non-irritating to the delicate skin around your eyes. Waterproof as well, this eyeliner won’t budge or smudge for a long period of time, relieving you from worries about getting panda eyes!

Best drugstore gel eyeliner 3 of 9
Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
Partnership with Maybelline
From RM31.93
See price at Hermo Malaysia

As one of the best drugstore companies around, Maybelline’s Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner has become a favourite of many people. This oil-free eyeliner has been getting rave reviews for being smudge-proof, water-proof and non-irritating. It is dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested and is safe for sensitive skin. 

Best for oily lids 4 of 9
3CE Gel Eyeliner
Partnership with 3CE
From RM111
See price at Lazada Malaysia
Also at Hermo Malaysia

Based on reviews from those with oily lids, this smudge-proof and waterproof gel eyeliner works wonders. This long-lasting eyeliner comes in a little pot and applies easily. It is super pigmented and a little goes a long way!

Best waterproof gel eyeliner 5 of 9
PRETTY VULGAR The Ink Gel Eyeliner
Partnership with
From RM113
See price at Sephora Malaysia

This gel eyeliner is as creamy as butter when you apply it, yet dries matte. It is one of the best waterproof gel eyeliners around, and has amazing staying power as it does not budge even when you accidentally rub your eyes or get rained on. 

Best for sensitive eyes 6 of 9
TARTE Amazonian Clay Pot Waterproof Shadow Liner
Partnership with TARTE
From RM84
See price at Shopee Malaysia

Tarte produces cruelty-free products that are paraben free and non-irritating for sensitive eyes, and this eyeliner is no exception. Available in 6 shades, this is also a great opportunity to experiment with popping colours! Formulated with Amazonian Clay, this gel eyeliner provides you with a long lasting wear that is smudge-proof and waterproof. 

Best for beginners 7 of 9
HOURGLASS 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner
Partnership with Hourglass
From RM81
See price at Sephora Malaysia

This mechanical gel eyeliner is suitable for beginners as it is easy to apply. Additionally, it goes on thinly so that you have control over how thick you want your eyeliner to be. It is also waterproof and stays on your lids for a long time. 

Best for hooded eyes 8 of 9
TARTE Kitten Eyeliner
Partnership with TARTE
From RM82
See price at Shopee Malaysia

For hooded eyes, this gel eyeliner makes drawing a winged liner easier as it glides on smoothly and is tug-free. It is also smudge-proof and waterproof with amazing pigmentation, so you won't have to keep retouching your makeup. 

Best for tightlining 9 of 9
MARC JACOBS BEAUTY Fineliner Ultra Skinny Gel Eye Crayon
Partnership with
From RM89
See price at Sephora Malaysia

With an easy application, this ultra skinny eyeliner glides on smoothly on your lids and is most ideal for tightlining. It has a fine tip to allow you to adjust how thick you want to draw or fill in your liner when tightlining. The formula is also waterproof and has strong staying power. 

Disclaimer: The pricing shown is just a good indication of how much these products are worth. The prices could change based on the e-commerce promotions that are going on. If some of the products are not available, do email us at [email protected]. Thank you!

More from ProductNation