Product in this article

Defined lashes are essential, even if you're going for a no-makeup look. The best mascaras have multi-benefits like lengthening, volumizing and curling your lashes. However, there's always a choice to make when you want to pick a mascara: waterproof or non-waterproof mascara.

What’s the difference between a waterproof and non-waterproof mascara?

Waterproof mascaras are great for special occasions like if you’re going to cry at a wedding or jump into a pool. However, using it every day can lead to dry, brittle eyelashes as the ingredients contained in waterproof mascaras are harsh.

Even though, waterproof mascaras are designed to last through storm clouds and Tsunamis, removing it can be very tricky compared to regular mascaras. It requires special eye makeup removals and lots of rubbing. That’s when a non-waterproof mascara comes in handy. Look for one from this list that can suit your needs.

Best mascara
Benefit Cosmetics
1. Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Mascara
Best overall non waterproof mascara

Benefit Cosmetics’ Roller Lash is known as the most versatile mascara. It accommodates every woman's lash needs, whether you have short lashes or straight lashes. One other thing that people love about this mascara is that it is water resistant but not water proof. Means it's very easy to remove with your normal makeup remover but doesn't smudge when wearing.

Best non waterproof, drugstore mascara
L'oreal Paris
2. L'oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Extatic Mascara
Best non waterproof, drugstore mascara

L'Oreal Volum Lash Paradise Extatic Mascara leaves your lashes full and thick but free from clumps. Its thin brush coats every individual lash and makes them long and fluttery. It can volumize and lengthen your lashes better than most of it’s drugstore counterpart.

Clinique
3. Clinique CliniqueFIT Workout 24-Hour Mascara
Best non waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes

This tube lifts, lengthens, curls and conditions your lashes with Jojoba oil to help them look fuller and softer. The CliniqueFIT Workout 24-Hour Mascara is dermatological-tested, fragrance-free, and suitable for contact lens wearer. Equipped with Advance Thermal Technology, it is smudge-proof, yet comes off easily with just warm water.

Best volumizing and curling mascara
Etude House
4. Etude House Lash Perm Curl Fix Mascara
Best non waterproof mascara that holds curl

Etude House Lash Perm Curl Fix Mascara features the lauded Etude Curl 24 hours technology which gives you fabulous curled lashes all day and night long. Also, the formula is lightweight, hence it will not weigh your lashes down. It’s so easy to remove that just lukewarm water is more than enough.

Best smudge proof non waterproof mascara
Revlon
5. Revlon Mega Multiplier Mascara
Best smudge proof non waterproof mascara

Revlon Mega Multiplier Mascara Blackest Black claims to plump and extend your lashes evenly from root to tip. The mascara glides through smoothly with no clumps and it is smudge proof, too. This mascara is available in blackest black, regular black, brown and plum brown hues.

Best non waterproof mascara for straight lashes
L'oreal Paris
6. L'oreal Paris False Lash Superstar Mascara
Best non waterproof mascara for straight lashes

L'Oreal False Lash Superstar Mascara lets you create ultra-long and voluminous lashes to achieve a gorgeous look. It’s designed with two brushes to grab and lift your lashes up for a better curling effect. If you have short, straight lashes, then this product is ideal for you.

Best non clumpy and non-waterproof mascara
Maybelline
7. Maybelline Great Lash Lots of Lashes Washable Mascara
Best non clumpy and non-waterproof mascara

If you have shorter eyelashes, then you’ll need to look for building mascaras that can give you the illusion of longer, more volumized lashes. Also, this unique heart-shaped brush is designed to go through your lashes from root to tip, so they will not look clumpy. Additionally, all you need is an oil-free makeup remover to clean your eyes, instead of pulling and tugging on your lashes.

Disclaimer: The pricing shown is just a good indication of how much these products are worth. The prices could change based on the e-commerce promotions that are going on. If some of the products are not available, do email us at [email protected] Thanks!

End of Article
More from Beauty

Save now, buy later. We’ll let you know if the price drops!